John Glenn College of Public Affairs, The Ohio State University
Monday, May 31, 2010
Obama Signs Law to Help Uganda Fight LRA Rebels
The Lord’s Resistance Army, or LRA, is a militant group based in Northern Uganda. Under the leadership of Joseph Kony, the LRA has been staging a violent rebellion against the Ugandan government for 23 years. The rebels regularly attack civilians in Uganda, Sudan, the Central African Republic, and the Democratic Republic of Congo. They are notorious for mutilating their victims and abducting children as soldiers.
Last Monday, President Obama signed into law the Lord's Resistance Army Disarmament and Northern Uganda Recovery Act of 2009. The new law gives the U.S. government 180 days to develop a multilateral strategy “to protect civilians from the Lord’s Resistance Army, to apprehend or remove Joseph Kony and his top commanders from the battlefield in the continued absence of a negotiated solution, and to disarm and demobilize the remaining Lord’s Resistance Army fighters.”
We will have to wait several months to see how the Obama administration moves forward with its strategy, but for now, the signing of this law is a monumental step towards eliminating the threat of the LRA and moving towards sustainable peace in Uganda and other unstable regions of Africa.
-Kristen
Sunday, May 30, 2010
Book Review: "Secrecy: The American Experience," by Daniel Patrick Moynihan
Secrecy: The American Experience (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1998), by Daniel Patrick Moynihan
The title of Archie Brown’s new history of the USSR, The Rise and Fall of Communism, is emblematic of the recent paradigm shift in the understanding of the Soviet experience. Modern Soviet scholarship is conducted largely under the purview of history. Twenty five years ago, study of the USSR was focused firmly on what was happening and more importantly what would come; few contemplated the possibility of a world without the Soviets. Particularly not during the 20th century.
Some foresaw the fall of the USSR years, even decades, in advance. Vide Daniel Patrick Moynihan. Michael Barone lauded him as “the nation's best thinker among politicians since Lincoln and its best politician among thinkers since Jefferson.” That designation is not so prestigious in the modern United States Congress (Moynihan probably wrote more books, 21, than most politicians have read), but it does not take away from Moynihan’s dexterous mind. During a career that took him from the New York governor’s mansion to the White House to a legendary quarter-century in the Senate, Moynihan cultivated a reputation as a pragmatic and professorial leader on a host of issues. Many of his most impassioned pleas for reform stemmed from his close involvement with oversight of the government’s intelligence community. During the bulk of Moynihan’s tenure in the Senate, the CIA and its companion agencies focused intensely on the Soviet Union. Their (secret) budgets allocated a tremendous amount of resources to the gathering and interpreting of Soviet intelligence, so much so that the CIA was occasionally accused of forgetting about the parts of the globe not hidden by the Iron Curtain.
The clandestine methods of the federal government began to raise questions in the latter half of the Cold War. The rationale for stamping trillions of documents “Top Secret” was not altogether clear. In Secrecy: The American Experience, Moynihan chronicles the surge in government secrecy that emerged after the Second World War and grew exponentially during the Cold War era. It was during the Cold War that government secrecy policy approached absurdity. A precedent-setting event occurred during the gathering of the Venona intercepts, cryptically coded cables sent by Moscow in 1943 to Communist figures in the United States. After several years of laborious code-cracking, the National Security Agency realized that a Soviet spy network had been established in America (as Moynihan notes, almost all of those spies and sympathizers lived in urban centers—McCarthy’s theory of a widespread menace was erroneous).
But this information was never made available to, of all people, the president. Harry Truman was excluded from the inner circle at the behest of General Omar Bradley, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, who labeled the Venona intercepts as Army property. Bradley’s sworn duty to assist the president in matters of national security was overwhelmed by his desire to hoard bureaucratic secrets; as a result, Truman’s knowledge of Soviet espionage never advanced beyond what the likes of McCarthy and J. Edgar Hoover wanted him to know.
The government became further consumed by Cold War-era secrecy, to the point at which “policy planners…did not entirely recognize when they had changed directions.” Moynihan notes that National Security Council report 68 (NSC-68), which offered detailed analyses of Soviet infrastructure, military, and politics, became for decades the premiere policy guide for federal officials. It was entirely based on classified information gathered by the intelligence community…and was almost entirely wrong. Its estimates of Soviet economic and military strength were wildly out of touch with reality. Moynihan’s frustration is evident when he remarks that the NSC could have drawn much more accurate information from the pages of the leading social sciences journals of the day.
His assertion that secret information is not inherently more accurate than public information leads Moynihan to disparage the CIA. This reflects Moynihan’s very public crusade against the CIA, an agency that he called outdated and archaic. He points out that the CIA budget was, by 1990, five times as large as the State Department’s. There is something undemocratic about such a vast sum being spent in almost total secrecy with little or no accountability, and this makes it hard not to empathize with Moynihan’s sturm und drang.
Efforts to reform government secrecy have been underfoot for decades. Moynihan gives vivid descriptions of the findings of the various Congressional commissions charged with streamlining the process but notes that all failed to reform intelligence gathering. Wearily, he makes a hopeful case for the dawn of a new era, one of openness. The internet has, Moynihan claims, opened the eyes of the world and seriously compromised a bureaucracy’s ability to hoard secrets. With open sources, we have the vast majority of information needed to make informed decisions. This, he says, will wear away at the notion that “clandestine collection…equals greater intelligence.” He quotes George F. Kennan, who legitimized containment theory, as an authority who asserts that “upwards of 95% of what we need to know about foreign countries could be very well obtained by the careful and competent study of perfectly legitimate sources of information open and available to us in the rich library and archival holdings of this country.” Would it were that American policy could function off of this directive. It could have saved untold sums and lives during the decades of posturing that ended in 1991. But was secrecy singularly responsible? It seems more plausible that the ideology of the Cold War (edified by government secrecy) played a bigger role in holding the West hostage; it was us vs. them without any room for disagreement. Indeed, Moynihan’s own belief in the eventual self-implosion of the USSR was ignored for well over a decade. When the collapse came, the intelligentsia sat stunned. Had we won? Well, yes. But the bureaucracies and their secrets did not carry the day.
-Mike Pawlows
Saturday, May 29, 2010
The US Capitol
SRF
Thursday, May 27, 2010
All I Ever Really Needed to Know I Learned in Kinder.. er.. Washington!
“There’s no way that this program relates to me, and my hospitality degree,” I thought to myself, but something told me to that I should find a little more information.
Eventually, I found myself on the road, headed to the nation’s capital, a place I had never been, about to work in hospitality’s seldom seen public sector. I was nervous for many reasons; a new city, moving in with 10 other students, starting a new job I knew very little about, and the future unknowns.
Though there are many reasons to be thankful for this experience, one that tops my list must be the broadening of my professional possibilities. I have gone through school studying hospitality, somehow turning a blind eye to the ever-important public sector and therefore never grasping a complete understanding of the hospitality industry as a whole. I can honestly say I have found it, here in Washington D.C., while working in the Department of Commerce in the Office of Travel and Tourism Industries. With this broad grasp of the industry, I have found something that I can take back to Columbus and pay forward to help our own program grow and prosper.
In retrospect, this has been an amazing experience and something that I will never forget. And it all leads back to one frigid winter morning in an ordinary accounting class in Columbus, Ohio…
AAM
Monday, May 24, 2010
The Ford's Theatre Museum
In November 1860 a sharply divided electorate chose Abraham Lincoln as the nation's 16th president. The Illinois Republican won barely 40% of the vote in a four-way contest. His party's opposition to the spread of slavery lad South Carolina, six weeks lare, to secede from the Union. Six other Southern states followed-with eight more slaveholding states hanging in the balance as Lincoln prepared to assume the presidency.
This quilt was made by two ladies for a fundraising auction at the 1864 Sanitary Fair in Philadelphia. With the start of the war, many who couldn't fight on the front lines-women, older men, religious leaders-wanted to volunteer and contribute to the Union war effort. In 1861 the government formed the United States Sanitary Commission to coordinate these efforts. The Sanitary Commission was a precursor to today's Red Cross. It was signed ny many well-known politicians, artists, and military and religious leaders including Abraham Lincoln. It was shamed that I couldn't recognize all names.
John Wilkes Booth was a famous actor and a conservative racist. He strongly didn't agree with President Lincoln's proposal of the abolition of slavery in the United States. He decided to kill President Lincoln.
After John Wilkes Booth shot the president at close range with his single shot deringer, he drooped the pistol on the floor of the theatre box. Pulling out his knife, he swiftly moved to jump over the balcony, grappling momentarily with Major Henry Rathbone, a guest of the Lincolns. Rathbone was severly cut in the brief scuffle with Booth and suffered major blood loss.
President Lincoln was taken to the Petersen House after the shooting and died there the following morning.
It was a good opportunity to learn about Abraham Lincoln's time in Washington, the civil war and the events leading up to his assassination. I would like to share President's a famous saying. "It is not merely for to-day, but for all time to come that we should perpetuate for our children's children this great and free government, which we have enjoyed all our lives." -Abraham Lincoln, August 22, 1864
-CL
Sunday, May 23, 2010
Holocaust Museum
SRF
Natural and American History Museums
Moving on to the American History Museum, I walked through the impressive collection of items ranging all the way from George Washington’s uniform to Kermit the Frog. I enjoyed walking through the different galleries and was impressed by the one that contained a house. Yes an actual house that was very old and scheduled for demolition had people petition for its safety and preservation and the Smithsonian saved it and put it on display, keeping track of all of its history and tracking down everyone that had lived there since it had been first built over 150 years before. They also had an interesting display about the Apollo theatre with items varying from one of B.B. King’s guitar to a beat box used by the Beastie Boys. Abraham Lincoln’s top hat and well known black suit were on display in an exhibit based on his life. There were countless items on display throughout the museum and you never really know what you will see the next time that you go because the amount of items that they have on reserve is even more vast. I think people would like either one of these museums; they have something for everybody to enjoy.
SRF
National Air and Space Museum
SRF
Saturday, May 22, 2010
Arlington National Cemetery
SRF
The White House
SRF
Tuesday, May 18, 2010
The Activity Checklist...and much more
As the weeks remaining in this internship are quickly being numbered, I begin to think about the wonderful experiences I have had over the course of the past several weeks. I vividly remember arriving out the outskirts of Washington D.C. and noticing the Capitol Dome peeking from within the trees and shrubbery. I shouted to my family to join me in staring in awe at my future home for 10 weeks. Once we arrived we aimlessly walked about the city, most likely we stood on the left hand side of the Metro escalators, behaved ourselves as tourists while gawking at motorcades and sirens (which I admittedly still do), and did everything possible to show to those around us that we were not Washingtonians. For a few days with the family, we attended the Friendship 7 exhibit, visited many National Monuments, and toured the Bureau of Engraving and Printing. While I was watching money being made in front of me, I can recall others absolutely amazed at the pallet of bills separated between them only by a incredibly strong pane of glass. I recall that the bills hadn't had as much of an effect on myself, and I knew it was because I used to work at a bank where handling money was routine. I was impressed, just not like the others, which led me to think "What will happen here which will in fact astound me so thoroughly that I will need to pinch myself to verify reality?" Little did I know that I was only weeks away from this. After my family left, I began to attempt to integrate myself, walking from shop to shop, and observing others to see what I could do to rid myself of my Columbus manners, and to be reborn a native of Capitol Hill. Time would tell. My first few weeks here included much sightseeing off of the Hill, National Cathedral, the Botanical Gardens, Folger Shakespeare Library, Library of Congress, etc. My first few weeks in the office were a Dream come true. As opposed to other interns who are stuck to administrative work, I was included in many meetings and office duties which seem to be reserved for non-interns in other offices. I began to realize that my amazement of my opportunities at work rivaled the amazement of those who were watching money being created with me weeks earlier. I dare to say that I was much more vigilant and gracious for what was transpiring at work, than many other interns. I began to fall in love with the mornings in which I would get the opportunity to spend another day in 113 Cannon House Office Building. Midway through the quarter is when the bread and butter of my memorable experiences may be recorded. Networking events, Private parties on the Hill, meeting leaders of different organizations, meeting ambassadors, and ultimately the interaction with congressmen, past and present, were so often happening that it began to seem perfunctory. Then I looked at my planner, and realized this dream world I was living in would soon end. As I was sitting in a congressional hearing regarding the stock market and its nearly 1000 point free fall, I was overcome with mixed feelings. I was saddened that I knew that those chances were limited, yet I was ecstatic to know that I would soon be home and recounting all these stories. I have been in the midst of it all. The most powerful country in the world has been my home and my employer. I only hope that as great as this experience has been, it will not tarnish the possibility of other internship opportunities in the future having as much of a profound effect on me. Yet, that may be the case, as I have considered these moments truly; once in a lifetime chances.
Tuesday, May 4, 2010
DEPOSITION: JERRY YOUNGBEY v. THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA
Ms. YoungBey contacted ACLU for legal assistance. When I heard of her case, I considered that it was obviously MPD fault. However, it was not easy to get through the deposition. The deposition was held in a small courtroom. There were ACLU interns, Metropolitan Police Department interns, the ACLU attorney, two witnesses, the Metropolitan Police Department attorney, a judge, and a court reporter. Every word of witness testimony was recorded during examination. After Jerry YoungBey and Rubin Butler were under oath to tell the truth and they must tell the truth, the deposition started.
There was a controversy on two issues between Ms. YoungBey and District of Columbia. ACLU argued that Plaintiffs had adequately alleged a Fourth Amendment Violation by the executing officers because the search was conducted in a constitutionally unreasonable manner. The unauthorized nighttime's execution of the warrant and the decision to enter without knocking and announcing independently made the manner in which this raid was carried out constitutionally unreasonable. On the other hand, Defendant District of Columbia argued that SWAT knocked on the door and identified themselves as police officers as police officers before breaking into the house. District of Columbia contested the fact that there was probable cause to believe that John YoungBey, the suspected murder, might be at his mother’s house or keep evidence linking himself to Malloy’s murder there, and that it was, therefore, appropriate to enter the premises at any time.
The Metropolitan Police Department attorney kept asking the same questions when witness felt nervous to answer questions. “Didn’t you know your son was suspected as the gunman?” “Have ever met John YoungBey before the day?” “Has John YoungBey ever been in your house?” Ms. YoungBey was in panic. However, she was able to avoid the difficult situation with the help of ACLU attorney. Asking questions and answering questions took for 6 hours and the deposition was finished. Through this unforgettable experience, I realized that it was really important to protect civil liberties. Of course, you can say "That’s none of my business." However, this case could happen to you or your family or your friends.
-CL
Oh, those airlines!
No one can deny the importance of air travel to the global economy, individual country GDP’s, and local citizens’ lives alike. It affects everyone, everywhere, even if you’ve never been on a plane if your life and that’s the same reason why this merger is so important. This merger is relatively close to providing the industry with a super-conglomerate, and becoming the “Simon-Says” conductor. This merger will create a carrier that will overtake Delta Air Lines, which just completed its own merger, as the world’s largest carrier.
A necessary and pertinent step in a merger is the consolidation process. Through this process, redundant routes between the individual carriers as well as some small city routes will be nixed. Ticket prices are also likely to increase. Industry analysts believe this would have happened anyways because we are coming out of a period in which we witnessed decade lows for ticket prices, so there is nowhere to go but up.
When the public sees increased ticket prices coupled with a decreased amount of flights to smaller cities, blame will be put on this merger. This shouldn’t be the case though. This merger leaves the door open for all of the smaller, regional discount airlines that fly more fuel efficient aircrafts to step up (Southwest, AirTran etc.). In turn, the larger legacy carriers (Delta, US Airways and the new United Airlines) will be forced to become extremely efficient by using their capital to create new airplane and flight technologies.
Moral of the story: don’t be one to persecute the merger when ticket prices increase, some flights are stopped and it looks like two or three mega-carriers are to blame. It will take time, but the smaller regional discount carriers will come around. Just like the old adage; eventually, everything has a way of working itself out.
AAM
Sunday, May 2, 2010
Sakura Matsuri Japanese Street Festival
Saturdays mean waking up to the sounds of the city instead of the screech of my alarm clock. Saturdays mean baguettes, brie, and brunch at the Eastern Market. And most importantly, Saturdays mean adventure.
On Saturday, April 10, after a wonderfully lazy morning, a group of us decided to explore a new corner of the city. With no real plans to speak of, Liz, Elise, Scott, Mike and I hopped on the metro and headed downtown. We found ourselves at the Sakura Matsuri Japanese Street Festival, a huge block party on Pennsylvania Avenue that celebrates the end of the annual Cherry Blossom Festival. Scott seems to disagree, but I found the festival incredibly interesting: we saw Godzilla, tried on kimonos, grooved to Japanese music, and even met President James Buchanan (…or maybe just a wax figure). I’d call that a fulfilling afternoon.
- Kristen